Six runners, two of them showing an edge, and the one we make most likely to win is the one stuck out in the widest gate.
The CF Orr Stakes is a $1 million Group 1 over 1400m at weight for age, and for 2026 it lands at Sandown with the track a Heavy 8 and showers about. Six runners, so no traffic horror stories and not much room to hide. The weights are the fixed age and sex scale, so there is no handicapper to blame and no reason to read anything into who carries what.
Our most likely winner is No.2 Pericles. We make him 27.0%, a fair price of $3.71, against a market price of $4.10. The market's chance after the margin is taken out is 23.9%, so the edge is +10.5%. He is one of two runners in the race where the market is bigger than our number. That does not make him the best value in the race, because most likely winner and best value are different questions, and with Pericles the likeliest winner still carries a smaller edge than the horse we like most on price.
The danger is No.1 Jimmysstar, last year's winner, who we make 21.8% against a market price of $3.95. The edge is -13.9%, so the favourite is a good deal shorter than we would have him. No.5 Beiwacht is $4.20 against our $4.83, an edge of -13.0%, so he is also under the odds.
The best value is No.8 Shadhavar, who is $7.00, fourth in the betting just behind Pericles. We make him 19.0%, and the edge is +33.3%, a touch bigger than Pericles shows. He has won his last two and deserves respect, but he is fourth in our order, not first, and a value runner is not the same as a likely winner. The book sits at 102.0%, so every price in this race is a little bit shorter than it should be.
Punty's Numbers
Runner
Punty Win %
Fair Odds
Market
Edge
TOP
#2 Pericles
27.0%
$3.71
$4.10
+10.5%
2
#1 Jimmysstar
21.8%
$4.59
$3.95
-13.9%
VALUE
#8 Shadhavar
19.0%
$5.25
$7.00
+33.3%
3
#5 Beiwacht
20.7%
$4.83
$4.20
-13.0%
Punty Says
Most likely winner: #2 Pericles (27.0%, fair $3.71)
Best value: #8 Shadhavar (19.0%, fair $5.25)
Danger: #1 Jimmysstar (21.8%, fair $4.59)
A positive edge isn't automatically a bet. My actual bets come from the tips card.
How I get there
Start with Pericles. We make him 27.0%, which converts to a fair price of $3.71. The market has him at $4.10, and once the bookmaker margin is stripped out that is a market chance of 23.9%. The edge is +10.5%, meaning the price is bigger than ours. That is a modest positive, with a wide barrier to get over. He stays on the right side of the ledger while the price is $4.30 or better.
The best value on the board is Shadhavar. We make him 19.0%, a fair price of $5.25, against a market price of $7.00, a market chance of 14.0% and an edge of +33.3%. He is fourth in our order, so this is a price argument and not a claim that he is likely to win. He stays interesting at $6.10 or better.
Jimmysstar is the danger. We make him 21.8%, fair $4.59, market $3.95, edge -13.9%, so the favourite is well shorter than we are. He gets interesting at $5.30 or better. Beiwacht sits behind him: we make him 20.7%, fair $4.83, market $4.20, edge -13.0%, and he gets interesting at $5.60 or better. A value horse is not a likely winner, and an under-the-odds horse is not a hopeless one.
The biggest gap in the wrong direction is Splash Back. He is $10.00 against our 8.4% chance, an edge of -15.8%. War Machine is $24.00 for a chance we rate at 3.0%, which is an exotics runner and not much more.
How this thing probably unfolds
Our map has two on the speed: Beiwacht from barrier 3 and Shadhavar from barrier 2. Both want to lead, and neither is a horse that likes to be taken on, so we expect a genuine tempo rather than a dawdle. If one blinks and takes a sit, it becomes a moderate tempo that suits whoever is handy. If neither does, they cook each other and the race opens up for those who come from behind.
The midfield is Pericles and War Machine. Both are drawn wide, in barriers 8 and 5, so they will either need cover or luck. That is a real problem for Pericles in particular, although a contested lead should bring the midfield into play, and he has shown he can win from just behind the speed.
The backmarkers are Jimmysstar and Splash Back. Our map rates this shape as hurting Jimmysstar most, since he has been taken back in recent runs and has a long way to make up. He is still second in our order, because his form and the barrier 1 draw carry him a fair way, but the market is keener on him than we are and a lot depends on the leaders going hard. In a six-horse field with a genuine tempo that is not a disaster, but it does mean the closers need things to open up late, and Sandown does not give you much time to find clear air.
The Heavy 8 is a bigger factor than the forecast showers. A heavy track is a grind, and it tends to blunt a late sprint and reward horses that are handy and can still stay on. Pericles has a heavy record with a win and four seconds from seven starts. Jimmysstar has no heavy run to go on.
Suggested race map
Lead
#5 Beiwacht
#8 Shadhavar
Midfield
#2 Pericles
#4 War Machine
Back
#1 Jimmysstar
#7 Splash Back
The race has seen some shit
The CF Orr Stakes is named after Charles F. Orr, a former chairman and secretary of the Williamstown Racing Club, and was first run at the now-closed Williamstown Racecourse in 1925. It has been a Group 1 since 1993, having been a Group 2 from 1979 to 1992. Typhoon Tracy won it twice, in 2010 and 2011.
The race was traditionally run in February to open the autumn, but it moved to November in 2025, so it was run twice that year. Ciaron Maher trained both of the 2025 winners: Another Wil in February and Jimmysstar in November. Jimmysstar won the November running as favourite by a length, his third Group 1 win and the 10th for Ethan Brown. In 2023 Gentleman Roy finished first but was relegated to second for interference, and the race went to Jacquinot. Sandown last hosted the race in 2023, and it returns there because Caulfield is being refurbished after the Caulfield Cup.
For punters, the patterns are all PUB STAT quality. Four of the last 10 winners started at $4 or shorter (n=10). Three of the last 10 paid $11 or more (n=10). Four of the last 10 winners were New Zealand-bred (n=10). Mike Moroney trained two of the last 10 winners, and Craig Williams and Luke Currie each rode two (n=10). All of these are headcounts of small samples. They are fun, but they are not a system.
The most useful pattern here is the one with a mechanism. Only one of the 10 winners came from the new November slot, and the other nine were February races where runners were resuming for the autumn (n=10, INTERESTING). November runners are coming out of the spring carnival. This field is exactly that: most of them have had Group 1 or Group 2 runs in the last month, which makes the old February patterns a weak guide.
The favourite angle is a coin flip dressed up as a trend. Four of the last 10 winners started at $4 or shorter (n=10, PUB STAT), and three paid $11 or more (n=10, PUB STAT). Both are true and neither tells you anything. In a field this size the market has Beiwacht at $4.20, which puts him in the short group, and Pericles at $4.10, so both ends of the range are live. Our numbers already account for the strength of the favourite, so we do not add a bonus for it.
Jimmysstar is the obvious tie to the record book, as the 2025 winner at a short price. That counts for little more than the fact he handles the race, and he has run poorly twice at Randwick since, so he sits second in our order and the market is a little keener on him than we are. The Hayes stable also trained the 2024 winner Mr Brightside and has War Machine here, who we rate a long way behind. Craig Williams rode two of the last 10 winners (n=10) and gets the leg-up on Pericles, who sits 1 in our order and is one of two runners showing value at the current price. We note it and move on. The New Zealand-bred pattern (n=10) cannot be applied here, as we do not have breeding for this field.
Market vs Punty
Runner
Verdict
2
Pericles
27.0%
$3.71
$4.10
23.9%
+10.5%
1
TOP CHANCE
1
Jimmysstar
21.8%
$4.59
$3.95
24.8%
-13.9%
2
STRONG CHANCE
5
Beiwacht
20.7%
$4.83
$4.20
23.4%
-13.0%
3
STRONG CHANCE
8
Shadhavar
19.0%
$5.25
$7.00
14.0%
+33.3%
4
STRONG CHANCE · VALUE
7
Splash Back
8.4%
$11.88
$10.00
9.8%
-15.8%
5
CHANCE
4
War Machine
3.0%
$32.79
$24.00
4.1%
-26.8%
6
EXOTICS
The raw market adds up to 102.0%, not 100%: that extra is the bookmaker's margin. Market % is each runner's implied chance (1 / odds) with that margin removed, so it compares fairly with my number. Edge is the market's odds against my fair odds.
Runner by runner
#1 Jimmysstar
Barrier 1 · J: Ethan Brown · T: C Maher · 59kg
Punty %
21.8%
Fair
$4.59
Market
$3.95
Edge
-13.9%
Rank
2/6
Profile: The danger · Last year's winner · Back-marker · Proven 1400m · Good and soft positive · Blinkers off
Jimmysstar won this race last year as favourite by a length, and the question is whether anything of that horse is still there. Since winning the Group 1 at Caulfield over 1200m last September he has run sixth and seventh, both at Randwick, and both with excuses: began awkwardly and held up on the straightening, then taken back from barrier 14. That is the sort of excuse that sounds better than it reads, but he gets barrier 1 here and a short field with less traffic. Our map has him at the back, though, and that is the run that suits this race least if the two leaders go hard early. His record is strong where it counts, with four wins from 11 at the trip and seven from 18 on good ground, and he is first up and second up good (small samples, EARLY READ). He has no heavy start to go on, which is a genuine question mark today. Blinkers come off for the first time, which is a coin toss on a horse that has been going badly. Maher's stable is a touch below expectation lately (last 100 starts, EARLY READ), but one hundred runners is noise, not a verdict. We rate him 2 in our order and make him 21.8%, a fair price of $4.59. The market is $3.95, an edge of -13.9%. He is a strong chance and the danger to our top pick, but the price is shorter than ours, and he becomes appealing at $5.30.
Profile: Most likely winner · Last-start Group 2 winner · Midfield from a wide gate · Proven 1400m · Heavy track placed
Pericles arrives off a Group 2 win at Randwick over 1300m at long odds, and the question is how much of that was the horse and how much was the race. He settled just behind the speed from barrier 2 and found the line, which is a trip that is harder to get from barrier 8. He has been held up before, so the outside gate is a genuine problem, although a contested lead up front should bring the midfield into play. Craig Williams is aboard, who rode two of the last 10 winners here (n=10, PUB STAT). He has five wins from 12 at the distance and seven from 25 on good ground, and on a heavy track he has one win and four seconds from seven starts, which suits the wet conditions today. We rate him 1 and make him 27.0%, fair price $3.71, against a market $4.10. The edge is +10.5%, so the market is bigger than us and he is one of two runners here showing value, though not the biggest edge. That does not make him a certainty of anything: a Group 2 winner stepping into a Group 1 from the widest gate still loses far more often than he wins, and our number is a long way short of even money. He stays interesting while the price is $4.30 or better.
Punty says:TOP CHANCE
#4 War Machine
Barrier 5 · J: Mark Zahra · T: Ben, Will & Jd Hayes · 59kg
Punty %
3.0%
Fair
$32.79
Market
$24.00
Edge
-26.8%
Rank
6/6
Profile: Group 3 winner at the trip · Midfield · Hayes stable in form
War Machine won a Group 3 over this trip at Caulfield last time as a short-priced favourite and has four wins from six at 1400m, which is a good record for a horse we make a long shot. The problem is the step up in class. Before that he was fourteenth in a Group 1 from barrier 16 after being keen and wide, and he is unlikely to find the Group 1 benchmark as easy as the Group 3 one. The Hayes stable is flying (last 100 starts, EARLY READ), and the same stable won this race with Mr Brightside. We rate him 6 and make him 3.0%, a fair price of $32.79, against $24.00. He is an exotics type, and any win would be a surprise rather than a scandal.
Punty says:EXOTICS
#5 Beiwacht
Barrier 3 · J: James McDonald · T: C J Waller · 59kg
Punty %
20.7%
Fair
$4.83
Market
$4.20
Edge
-13.0%
Rank
3/6
Profile: On the lead · Unbeaten at the trip · Short price
Beiwacht is a strong chance, and the thing that stands out is that he has won all three starts at 1400m, including a Group 1 at Caulfield last August by three lengths. His last two runs were thirds at Randwick, in a Group 1 at 1500m and a Listed race at 1300m, beaten a length and a bit each time, both from a forward position. In between was a bad Group 1 at Caulfield over 1200m where he began awkwardly and overraced, which is a reasonable thing to forgive. Our map has him on the lead again, but Shadhavar from barrier 2 is the other horse that wants the front, so he may have to work for it. He now has James McDonald aboard instead of Nash Rawiller. Barrier 3 is good for a horse who wants to be forward. The doubts are the second-up record (second placed on three of four, never a win) and that 59kg is more than he has carried. A small sample, so no conclusion. We rate him 3 and make him 20.7%, a fair price of $4.83. The market is $4.20, so the edge is -13.0%. He is rated behind Pericles and Jimmysstar, and the market is shorter than us on him, so a strong chance does not mean value. He gets more interesting at $5.60 or better.
Splash Back has won at Sandown over this trip, one from one at the track and the distance, and has won a Group 1 at Eagle Farm over 1400m in June, after being hampered at the start and awkwardly placed. He has also won one of two on a heavy track, which is a small point in his favour today. Since then he has been fifth in a Group 2 at Flemington over 1200m, which is the wrong trip and a weak result. He carries just 57kg on the scale, a few kilos less than most of the field. Our map has him at the back, so he will need a genuine tempo. He has first-up and second-up wins, though samples are small. We rate him 5 and make him 8.4%, a fair price of $11.88, against $10.00. The edge is -15.8%, so the market is a lot shorter than we are and there is no win value at the current price. Our place chance is 24.1%, which is a different question to the win. On our numbers he is a rough chance to win, and far more likely to lose than win.
Profile: Best value · Two straight wins · On the lead · Group 1 test · Quick back-up
Shadhavar has won his last two, a Group 2 at Caulfield and a Group 3 at Flemington by four lengths, both over 1400m and both from near the speed. The form is real, and this time the price gives us something to work with. He is $7.00, a market chance of 14.0%, and we make him 19.0%, a fair price of $5.25. That is an edge of +33.3%, so the market is bigger than us, and he is the best value runner in the race. He is fourth in our order, so this is a price argument and not a claim that he is the likeliest winner. The risks are plain. His wins are in Group 2 and Group 3 company, and he steps up to Group 1 grade here, which he has not done in his recent runs. He is also back in just nine days, and he has no heavy start to go on, with two wins from nine on soft ground. Barrier 2 and our map have him on the lead alongside Beiwacht, and a speed duel is the risk for both. His record of 5 wins from 7 at class level is good (small sample, EARLY READ). A repeat of the Flemington win would put him right in it. He stays interesting while the price is $6.10 or better.
Punty says:STRONG CHANCEVALUE
If the track changes
The track is a Heavy 8 with the rail on the true entire circuit, and showers are in the forecast. That is a proper wet one, and form on good ground only goes so far. Pericles has a win and four seconds from seven heavy starts, which is the best wet-track evidence in the field. Splash Back has won one of two on a heavy track. Jimmysstar has a strong record on good and soft ground but no heavy start to go on. The track is the same for all six, so this is a question of who gets bothered by it, not who gets the benefit.
Punty's Final Word
1. #2 Pericles
Most likely winner, with an edge of +10.5% and the market above $4.30. Heavy form is good, barrier 8 is not.
2. #8 Shadhavar
Best value in the race, though only fourth in our order, with an edge of +33.3%. Interesting at $6.10 or better, though he has to survive a speed duel on a Heavy 8.
3. #1 Jimmysstar
The danger, second in our order and under the odds at $3.95, with an edge of -13.9%. Last year's winner, though the market is leaning on that a little. Appealing at $5.30.
4. #5 Beiwacht
Third in our order, and the price is shorter than our number, with an edge of -13.0%. He gets more appealing at $5.60 or better.
Betting recommendations come from the tips card, which can change with scratchings and the market. The preview above is analysis.
Last updated: Saturday 14 November 2026, 4:00pm Melbourne time
Questions
What distance is the CF Orr Stakes?
The CF Orr Stakes is run over 1400m. It is a weight-for-age Group 1 for three-year-olds and up, worth $1 million in 2026.
Where is the 2026 CF Orr Stakes being run?
At Sandown. Caulfield is being refurbished after the Caulfield Cup, so the race is listed at Sandown for 2026, the first time since 2023.
Why has the CF Orr Stakes moved to November?
The race was traditionally run in February to open the autumn, but it moved to November in 2025 and was run twice that year. That means the old patterns are based on a different point in the season (n=10, INTERESTING).
Who is the favourite for the CF Orr Stakes?
No.1 Jimmysstar is the market favourite at $3.95. Our most likely winner is No.2 Pericles at 27.0%, and Jimmysstar is the danger at 21.8%, so the market has the favourite shorter than we do, with an edge of -13.9%.
Who is the danger in the CF Orr Stakes?
No.1 Jimmysstar, last year's winner. We make him 21.8% against a market price of $3.95, an edge of -13.9%, so the price is shorter than ours. Our map has him at the back, which is the run this shape suits least.