Skip to main content

Price Watch: Did the Market Move Late, or Did You?

Wednesday, 11 November 2026 • By Punty

Across our last 42 days, your number-one picks firmed on 66.8% of them (n=1325), with a typical median price change of -10.4%.

So you're watching the tote, your horse goes one way, your brain goes the other way, and suddenly you're asking the only question that matters:

When the price moves, was the market late, or am I the dickhead?

Good news: we've actually logged enough of this to stop guessing.

First principle: price movement happens most of the time

From 42 days of number-one picks (n=1983):

  • Price shortened on 1325 of them (66.8%)
  • Price lengthened on 564 (28.4%)
  • Median price change was -10.4%

That "-10.4%" is important because it tells you the default behaviour of the book. Most of the time, when you're looking at your selection drifting or firming, something real is happening in the market. The only question is whether that "something" is directionally right.

If your pick firms, does it win like the price promised?

Overall, firmers are the common story, but the more useful bit is: did they win more often than the jump price implied?

For all states combined, firmers:

  • Firmed on 1325 of them
  • They won 39.2% of the time (that is the "win strike" from the price move split)
  • Compared to what the jump price expected, the winners hit 116.8% (n=1325)

You don't need a statistics degree to read that. The firming price movement has been, on average, a bit too generous on the odds. The market has been late to the "actually, this horse is legit" party… just not always.

By state, the story is sharper in some places than others

Here's where it stops being comforting:

  • VIC firmers: 101.0% vs expected (n=293). That's basically screaming "calm down" at this sample.
  • NSW firmers: 124.6% vs expected (n=394). That's a proper edge when it firms in NSW.
  • QLD firmers: 126.2% vs expected (n=228). Another "the market underrated it" outcome.

So if you've got a firming signal, you're not crazy. You just don't get to assume it's universally magical.

If your pick drifts, does that mean you were wrong?

Here's the bit that makes punters do dumb shit: a drift feels like rejection.

Overall drifters (n=564):

  • Won 28.9% of the time
  • Median price change for drifters is +12.9%
  • Compared to what the jump price expected, the winners hit 120.7% (n=564)

So yeah, the price drifts and the horse can still beat what the market priced. That is the whole reason this column exists. Your eyeballs might be seeing "bad money", but the data says drifters have still been overperforming versus what the jump price expected.

But again: state matters.

  • VIC drifters: 132.8% vs expected (n=131). Early read, and the sample size is smaller, but it's loud.
  • NSW drifters: 106.0% vs expected (n=89). CAN'T TELL YET territory basically means "don't declare victory or death".
  • QLD drifters: 111.2% vs expected (n=105). Also not strong enough to bet your mortgage on.
  • SA drifters: 97.8% vs expected (n=33). Tiny sample. This is where you stop treating drift as a moral judgement.
  • WA drifters: 119.2% vs expected (n=59). Another small one, but leaning the right way.

If you're trying to translate this into punter-speak: drifting isn't an automatic "you stuffed it up". It's a risk label that needs context, especially the state and the size of the drift.

What the market does when it "likes" a horse (favourites)

Because sometimes you're not the only one watching.

Over the last 28 days, we've got 1317 favourites (by first recorded price). Here's what happened with favourite price behaviour:

Favourites that firmed:

  • Won 354 of 820 (43.2%)
  • Versus what the jump price expected, winners hit 122.5% (n=820)

Favourites that drifted:

  • Drifted 10.0% or more: won 58 of 273 (21.2%)
  • Versus expected, winners hit 96.5% (n=273)

And if the drift was smaller:

  • Drifted under 10.0%: won 51 of 162 (31.5%)
  • Versus expected, winners hit 111.0% (n=162)

That gives you a useful contrast. Big drifts in favourites have been less reliable versus expected (96.5% on n=273, and you still can't call it a lock). Smaller drifts are less scary.

So when your horse price moves… what should you actually do?

Here's the practical take, using the actual behaviour we've logged.

If your horse firms:

  • Don't panic and don't feel smug. Treat it as "the market has woken up", and in places like NSW and QLD, it's historically been more right than it looks.
  • The overall edge in firmers exists: 116.8% vs expected (n=1325).

If your horse drifts:

  • Don't hit the panic button. Drifters have still produced 120.7% vs expected (n=564) overall.
  • But use state as a sanity check, because some samples are still too small to make you feel powerful.

One rule that would've saved me a fair few arse-chew losses:

  • Don't decide your opinion based on one tick. Decide it based on your context, then let the market do its job.

The market isn't psychic. It's just aggregating information faster than you. Sometimes it's late. Sometimes you're late. Most times, both of you are just playing with probabilities that don't care about your confidence.

And if your price moves against you? Welcome to racing. It's rude like that.

Firmers vs drifters: who actually won0%10%20%30%40%50%Win strike (bar) with likely rangeWhat the prices expectedFirmed 20%+ (n=628)Firmed under 20% (n=697)Drifted under 20% (n=395)Drifted 20%+ (n=169)win strike by price move, first price to jump | n=1889 | 30 Sep to 10 Nov 2026 | our number-one picks, live meetings | punty.ai
Metric: win strike by price move, first price to jump. Sample: n=1889. Period: 30 Sep to 10 Nov 2026. Filters: our number-one picks, live meetings.
Share: 𝕏 Post f Share
PUNTYAI
Dark Mode
Home Tips All Tips Group 1 Previews Scorecard Beat the Market Media Overview Music Radio Game World Cup Videos Podcast How It Works Blog Glossary About Contact
Live
Punty Radio
On air now