Tempted at Flemington Race 6: why $1.98 still stung Punty
After 408 bets for a P&L of +$1,055.23 (ROI +22.0%), Tempted at $1.98 still managed to deck me at Flemington Race 6.
The ledger, in case you're here for facts
From 02 Nov to 08 Nov 2026, you've backed 408 bets and got 172 winners (42.2% strike). You staked $4,791.00 and the result was P&L +$1,055.23, which is ROI +22.0%. That's not vibes. That's accounting.
Win bets were where it mostly happened: 320 bets, 132 winners (41.2% strike), staked $3,827.50, P&L +$1,102.45, ROI +28.8%. The "hope-and-a-prayer" stuff went quieter: each way 74 bets, 36 winners (48.6% strike), staked $886.00, P&L -$46.52, ROI -5.3%. Place bets were basically a museum exhibit: 14 bets, 4 winners (28.6% strike), staked $77.50, P&L -$0.70, ROI -0.9%.
So yeah, overall we did the job. But the market doesn't care how you're tracking in November. It'll still stitch you up when your $1.98 plan goes sideways.
Yep, nailed that (short version)
- Ottalaus ($10.00 each way) delivered at Echuca Race 7 for P&L +$82.50.
- Viipuri at Hawkesbury Race 6 ($7.00) won for P&L +$78.00.
- Overshoot at Warren Race 2 ($6.00) won for P&L +$75.00.
Well, that went to shit: Tempted and the $1.98 faceplant
My most confident number-one pick that flopped was Tempted (No.6) at Flemington Race 6, win at $1.98. It finished outside the top four, and it cost me P&L -$15.00.
Here's why this one hurts, and why it's not just "bad luck" folklore.
At $1.98, you're basically paying to be right more than you're paying to win. My win chance for Tempted was 48.7%. That's already telling you something important: this wasn't some lock that should've mugged the field on the line. It was a strong lean, but it was still a coin-flip-ish world. The chance of "wrong" was real, it just wasn't the part my ego wanted to think about.
What makes it sting is the timing of the mistake. I backed a near favourite, then it didn't deliver the outcome needed. The market didn't "betray" me. It just made me pay for being human: you can be calibrated and still get a losing run from a high-uncertainty bet type.
Also, you might've noticed the second sentence where my brain tried to cope:
- Tempted had a win chance of 48.7%
- It ran outside the top four
That mismatch is the lesson. Probability isn't destiny. It's expectation. You don't get to demand the universe behave because your number looked decent.
(And yes, the other horror story was Official Business at Ascot Race 1 at $1.85, P&L -$13.50, win chance 47.7%, also outside the top four.)
The Market Knew: late money that actually won
Sometimes the market moves because the horse is doing something, and sometimes it moves because punters are bored and opinionated. This week, some of it was genuinely informative.
- Taupo Race 2: Allez Be Be won and firmed hard from $21.00 to $6.50 (-69.0%). My pick Woman In Charge lost.
- Sha Tin Race 11: Beauty Bolt won, firming from $9.00 to $2.90 (-67.8%). My pick Mr Incredible lost.
- Coffs Harbour Race 6: Mama Tried won, firming from $34.00 to $11.00 (-67.6%). My pick Stormy Martini lost.
This is the uncomfortable point: I can have my own number-one, but the market can still be more right, earlier, later, or both. When a price gets smashed like that, it's usually because something changed. Sometimes the change is form. Sometimes it's fitness. Sometimes it's a queue of rats with a spreadsheet and confidence.
Either way, you can't treat drift as decoration.
The Market Was Drunk: my numbers held up better than the book
There were also times where the "movement" didn't work as a warning label.
- Taupo Race 1: Sweet Disposition drifted from $2.00 to $3.00 (+50.0%) and won. My win chance was 35.0%.
- Hobart Race 3: White Moon drifted from $2.75 to $4.00 (+45.5%) and won. My win chance was 17.2%.
- Wangaratta Race 5: Cumbrian Queen drifted from $3.90 to $5.50 (+41.0%) and won. My win chance was 23.6%.
So what's the takeaway? Price movement is a clue, not a rule. If your number says "still value", you don't automatically abandon it because the book looked smug for a moment.
One race doesn't prove shit: expected versus actual (and why you should care)
This week's sample is big enough to stop pretending our results are mystical.
My number-one picks: winners vs expected came out at 122.5% (n=393). In plain terms, more of them won than the average of my win chances suggested. The label attached to that result says it's "likely between 107.8% and 137.3%", which is basically the stats way of saying "yes, but don't start a cult".
Even more spicy, for horses I rated under 15%:
- winners vs expected was 202.6% (n=7)
That number is screaming "small sample", because n=7 is the statistical equivalent of arguing with a weather forecast using only your feelings.
The real moral is simpler: a result is not probability. Winning doesn't validate your model. Losing doesn't disprove it. Calibration is the judge, and your bank account is the courtroom.
What changes next week?
Not a lot of magic, but the week does support a couple of practical attitudes:
[FINDING] This week's ROI was +22.0% (n=408), so we're not running pure noise. That doesn't mean we keep pressing anything blindly, it just means the process isn't broken.
[EARLY READ] The "higher confidence" picks, where I rated 35% and up, beat expectation at 134.4% (n=105). That's an early read, not a guarantee, but it suggests those decisions are pulling their weight.
From the Horse's Mouth: the ledger column stuff worth reading
- Punty Award, track of the week: Hawkesbury, P&L +$153.80.
- Best call (winner I rated furthest above the market): Tivacious, Sunshine Coast Race 3, my chance 48.0% vs the market's 26.0%.
- Worst call: Tempted, Flemington Race 6, my chance 48.7%, ran outside the top four.
- Painful beat (number-one pick ran 2nd at the best price): Verbier, Happy Valley Race 6 at $12.00.
- Funniest result (longest-priced collect, any bet type): Genius Baby, Sha Tin Race 4, place at $14.00, P&L +$14.30.
The weekend's feature races: who won, and how my top pick went
Here's the feature-race reality check you can't argue with:
- Flemington Race 6, Champions Sprint (Group 1): Point Barrow won at $19.00. My number-one pick Tempted ran outside the top four.
- Flemington Race 7, Champions Mile (Group 1): Autumn Glow won at $1.17. My number-one pick Autumn Glow won.
- Flemington Race 8, Champions Stakes (Group 1): Birdman won at $5.50. My number-one pick Cosmic Crusader ran 2nd.
- Riccarton Park Race 10, NZ 1000 Guineas (Group 1): Angels Halo won at $29.00. My number-one pick Asturia ran 3rd.
- Te Rapa Race 1 (Group 1): Helena Bel won at $2.60. My number-one pick Helena Bel won.
- Ascot Race 9 (Group 2): King Of Light won at $1.95. My number-one pick King Of Light won.
- Flemington Race 5 (Group 2): Sun Gift won at $51.00. My number-one pick Too Darn Discreet ran 2nd.
- Rosehill Race 7 (Group 2): Lazzura won at $1.30. My number-one pick Lazzura won.
- Flemington Race 3 (Group 3): Pinhole won at $2.60. My number-one pick Pinhole won.
- Riccarton Park Race 7 (Group 3): Moving Melody won at $2.30. My number-one pick Bona Sforza ran 3rd.
So yeah. The overall ledger looks fantastic. Tempted just reminded me that even at $1.98, you're still buying a chance. Sometimes the chance walks out the back door and pretends it never met you.